FitJerks Blog

Dark Light
The Theory Of Bodyweight Memory™


Submit to FitMarker

email

You are about to read one of my most recent and brand-spanking new theories that just might change the way you think about weight management. I call it, Bodyweight Memory.

The idea came about on Friday the 13th (how ironic eh?) when I was looking at some hard data of my own bodyweight over the years along with some of my logs. I’m one of those people that writes everything down… if I had troubles, it’s going in the log. If a workout was awesome and I had no problems, then that shit is also going in my log also. One interesting thing I found was that when I wanted to fluctuate between my previously acquired weight, it wasn’t much of a problem. Could be done within a month or two. But when I wanted to beyond what I had achieved in the past… now all of a sudden the task was exponentially harder. Let’s look into an example.

My weight and body fat rangers between these two levels: 130 @ 6%BF & 150 @ 7-8%BF. The picture most of you see of me is of when I was at 140 at around 6%BF… and my protocol to get there is simple. Bust my ass and feed for about 6 weeks till I’m 150, then spend 2 weeks cutting down to around 145-140 so I can look lean, mean and sexy for the camera. I’ve done this for years and the odd thing is that it doesn’t matter if I’m at 130, 135 or 140… getting to 150 never takes me more than 6 weeks. It’s like my body knows

However, when I once tried to go above 150 – it was fucking hell. It was not impossible (I hit 153) but the effort required almost doubled. I had to stuff my face even at times when my stomach feels full and while it was no fun, it was the only way to see results. On the contrary, I’m sure if I ever tried to drop below 130 my body would tell me to go take a hike and/or jump off a bridge… but not that I would, it’s too light even for power tumbling reasons.

Now, I figured this might just be me or whatever and so I didn’t pay much attention to it. But then I got curious and started to look at the data from my E-Training clients. What I found was that my little “hunch” was true across the board. Those that said they were “fit” in the past actually saw progress much faster, had less challenges and therefore sent me less “I’m having trouble with this…” type emails than than those that had never been in shape before. Don’t get me wrong, both groups saw progress, but one group was clearly ahead in terms of speed. Hmm… interesting.

Its Like Muscle Memory

I concluded this data into my new little theory. You see, just like Muscle Memory (which as been proven), I believe you possess something called Bodyweight Memory. If there was a weight you’ve been at before, then your body remembers all the physiological conditions and nuances that need to be true in order to be at that weight… which could explain why weight loss (or gain) can be challenging for most people. Add this to the fact that your body loves to be at homeostatis (the weight you’re currently at) and that once you gain fat cells you can never get rid of them – just deplete them, and you soon realize why people like Oprah and Kristie Alley bounce back to their floor-shattering weight. Now, some even manage catapult beyond because they obviously eat more… which we know as the yo-yo effect.

“Where Is The Scientific Proof?”

Well that’s the damn problem, I was hoping that there would be actual scientific data backing this up but apparently I’m the first person to dream up this little hypothesis. Or the first to publically write about it… either way, the data from studies isn’t there to support this exact theory. But I’ll tell you what is there – real world experiences. I’ve run this little theory by a few extremely smart individuals and each have reported back saying something along the lines of “now that you mention it, I too have noticed this… it’s much easier for me to reach a weight I’ve been at before”, and it’s comforting to hear this because now I know that I’m not talking out of my ass.

left-hanging-shirt So where does this leave us? Well… realistically speaking it leaves us all hanging. I don’t have the massive amount of cash necessary to fund a study like this because truth be told, designing one to try and prove this theory would not only be intensive, it would take a while (and I’d want it peer-reviewed!). These are important factors that would jack up the cost for whoever is funding it – but I believe the conclusive data would be very revealing and quite beneficial to this whole weight loss field (Hey universities – are you listening?)

As it stands right now, I’m fairly convinced that Bodyweight Memory is a very real, and that most people will experience this phenomenon. It gives me a whole new understanding of how people lose weight which in turn will help me refine my program and products even further so people can look as sexy as possible in the shortest amount of time.

However, I do need to end off by saying one thing to those that don’t know what I’m all about… DO NOT USE THIS AS A FUCKING EXCUSE!

I always have some trepidation when writing about such new ideas (of which I have lots) because many will misinterpret the information and then use it as a crutch to justify why they can’t reach their goals; “Oh I can’t lose/gain weight because of Bodyweight Memory… I just can’t do it… my body’s never been there before!” – If I catch you spewing this nonsense, I’ll kick your ass. Seriously.

Even if a study comes around in the future and proves the concept of Bodyweight Memory to be true (or untrue), there is no reason you need to use this as a crutch. I’d say it solely exists as a teaching concept for program designers and coaches then for the average person who has a life outside of health, sports and weight management. Which means you really shouldn’t be reading this in the first place… shit. Oh well.

- FitJerk

Discuss: Have you experienced this theory to be true in your own life? Comment below and let me know.

Content originally written by FitJerk for www.fitjerk.com – © 2010 All Rights Reserved – This post is NOT to be republished without author consent under any forms of media (including print, internet, video or audio transcription). Doing so is a violation against copyright law and is punishable by deathly fines.

———–
© 2010 – 2012, By FitJerk. FitJerk.com is a division of Flawless Fitness Media – All Rights Reserved – No part of this post is to be republished without author consent under any forms of media (including print, internet, video or audio transcription). Doing so is a violation against copyright law and should be punishable by a punch to the face. All images are copyright of their respective owners.

Only LOSERS have nothing to say or discuss. Put your thoughts, comments or general rants in the comment section below. FJ does not use censorship but obvious racial slurs and over-the-top stupidity will be deleted.

GD Star Rating
loading...
The Theory Of Bodyweight Memory™, 4.0 out of 5 based on 1 rating
* Name:

* Email:




Tired Of Looking Ordinary? Click Here To Train Personally With FJ!


29 Comments
  • Crista
    August 23, 2010
    Reply #1
    GD Star Rating
    loading...

    One, I love that my security word was “cougar”… ahahahaha! now I do believe there’s something to bodyweight memory. I don’t use it as an excuse and I work my a$$ off. but I will say this my highest weight was 137lbs and my lowest weight 117lbs. I have to be sick and uncomfortable to be 137lb and I have to be not sleeping and sick to get down to 117lbs. But when my body gets to 128 it is a huge effort to get lower OR to put on weigh. my body loves that weight. sometimes with very precise training and diet I get down to 125 and can maintain and with huge effort and a bit of stress I can get to 120 and hold it for a bit. BUT my body knows, KNOWS how to maintain 128. it loves this weight and is extremely comfortable here. I don’t know all the factors that go into why and how I get and stick at that weight. and I’d love to figure out the hows and why and how I could get lower and stay there comfortably

    • - Fit Jerk -
      August 24, 2010
      Reply #2
      GD Star Rating
      loading...

      Oh there are plenty more security words for you to discover… its like Pokemon. But you gotta find em’ all. Or some shit.

      If your weight is “stuck”, it’s most probably because of your eating habits assuming your workouts are intense enough and frequent enough. Play with the ratios… add more protein and remove some carbs. Track it and you’ll get to where you need to be.

  • Jared
    August 23, 2010
    Reply #3
    GD Star Rating
    loading...

    I’m glad to hear that i’m not the only one who has notice this. i honestly think this is a pretty solid theory and in time proven to be true. I’ve been around 160 – 180 for the past few years and i notice that its easy for me to gain muscle/lose fat when i’m around 165-175 but once i hit, the 180 mark, pffff!! its feels practically impossible to make any gains. lol! vice versa for when i try to drop back down to 160. No excuses here, i just try to keep my body guessing by making new workouts. overall its just an INSANE amount of effort once i hit those points.

    • - Fit Jerk -
      August 24, 2010
      Reply #4
      GD Star Rating
      loading...

      Insane is right. One thing you can try is appetite stimulants… since you’ll have to eat when your brain tells you that no more food is needed. It’s a mental wrestling match. Tell it to stfu and eat anyway.

  • Mitch
    August 23, 2010
    Reply #5
    GD Star Rating
    loading...

    FJ, This is a good theory. I’ve experienced this definately before. I’m a very hard gainer. I fluctuated between 148 and 145 for years until I got serious about my training. Then I was able to push up 158, but 160 seems to be out of reach. The amount of food it takes to get there just seems to be crazy. I can get up to 155 no problem, but beyond that truly doubles the effort. I’m on a quest to 165 or 170, then cutting down to 6% at 160 or so. So I feel your pain. Great thinking. This industry needs more ideas like this rather than all the recycled stuff out there. Thanks man.

    Mitch

    • - Fit Jerk -
      August 24, 2010
      Reply #6
      GD Star Rating
      loading...

      I hear that. Recycled nonsense wrapped up in pretty packaging is what’s been going on lately. I’ll see which one of my other ideas I can streamline.

  • eilat
    August 23, 2010
    Reply #7
    GD Star Rating
    loading...

    This explains why my weight sticks to around 130. I would love to be 120 but find it very hard to hold that weight for any length of time. If I go over 130 I have no trouble dropping back to 130 in a day or two. Thanks for this thought.

  • Jody - Fit at 52
    August 23, 2010
    Reply #8
    GD Star Rating
    loading...

    Well, for me, I maintain right in this 115-117 range with a lot of hard work doing cardio, weights & eating clean. If I go off this protocol & especially at my age, all hell breaks loose & I gain weight… especially if I eat the same or more & do less. Even when I was younger, this was the case.

    For me, it is VERY VERY easy for me to gain weight. I do not have to work at it & it happens even with clean food if I eat more than I am burning off and it keeps going up. For me, I don’t think I have this set bodyweight memory. Yes, if I wanted life to be easier & have more body fat, it is easier for me to stay around 120-122 BUT it is also easy for me to get past that & beyond.

    Maybe cause I have all those shrunken fat cells waiting to expand from when I was heavy when I was younger OR maybe for men this works more than for women….

    Don’t know FJ but I don’t think it quite fits for my crazy body!!!! I may be the exception though.

    • - Fit Jerk -
      August 24, 2010
      Reply #9
      GD Star Rating
      loading...

      There could indeed be many things Jody. It could be the fact that you were heavier in the past and now have gotten to a very respectable weight… so there is that huge range which your body remembers. Your fat cells are definitely a factor, but through proper insulin control and workouts that shouldn’t be too much of a problem; in fact it looks like it isn’t, since you’re kicking ass.

      And the theory might also affect age differently… maybe it starts to lose effectiveness and accuracy as the age increases? Like an inverse relationship?

      Duno. These are the questions that bug me which is why more data would be helpful. I’ll be looking and post any important shit I find.

  • Yolanda Facio
    August 23, 2010
    Reply #10
    GD Star Rating
    loading...

    I’m very surprised at the lack of hard data. Somewhere in the deep recesses of my memory I recall hearing something to this effect; the idea that our bodies choose a weight it likes and it’s hard to move past it. I’d love more info on this as well as what you can do to overcome it.

    • - Fit Jerk -
      August 24, 2010
      Reply #11
      GD Star Rating
      loading...

      I am too… but I’ll be on the hunt. Or I’ll bother some hardcore nerds and prod them to see if there is more data to support this.

  • murffi
    August 24, 2010
    Reply #12
    GD Star Rating
    loading...

    I have read about this in one or more Lyle McDonald’s books and I think it is mentioned in Tom Venuto’s BFFM as well.

    • - Fit Jerk -
      August 24, 2010
      Reply #13
      GD Star Rating
      loading...

      Do you know which exact book it was by Lyle?

      • Tony C.
        August 31, 2010
        Reply #14
        GD Star Rating
        loading...

        It”s called setpoint, and is found on page 12 of “A Guide to Flexible Dieting”, by Lyle McDonald.

  • ZacharyB
    August 24, 2010
    Reply #15
    GD Star Rating
    loading...

    I have to say I believe this too. Thinking about the people I know in my life who have always been active, there weight has always been in a “usual” fluctuation depending on their activities currently being conducted. I wish I could say I know this is first hand but i know i am on the younger side, 21, and really I have just started to take my training real seriously (turning pro in boxing Sept. 18th at 147lbs), that and my weight loss story is the kind on paper (or should i say the Internet?) you would probably not believe it. being that 6 years ago I was obese. With that being said I can and say that I have no problem putting on weight (fat) but have never personally tired to put on straight muscle because of my boxing. I can chime in and say when I stop training, I put on weight unbelievable fast, almost like my body remembers being fat, ha.

  • jO
    August 24, 2010
    Reply #16
    GD Star Rating
    loading...

    yes, yes, I was just saying to my partner a couple of days ago that I believe I have a set point weight of 59-60kgs. I never go over unless I’m shocking for weeks which never happens anymore anyway. And I just can’t get below no matter how strict I am.
    My set point used to be about 63-64kgs years ago before I changed the way I train and eat, so I truly believe it exists, but you can change it over the long (long, long, long) term.
    Jo

  • IrishPaul
    August 26, 2010
    Reply #17
    GD Star Rating
    loading...

    Hi FJ,
    This is something I have spoken about with friends for a few years. I definitely think you are right, and onto something here. There was actually a BBC (UK) doco about wieght loss about last year/18 months ago. Part of it was that they took a load of students and force fed them 10k Cal per day with no exercise. Some put on weight, some put on minimal extra. Then they got them to lose it and again, some had no prob returning to “normal” and some had real effort getting it off again. I’ll have a look and post it if i can find anything on the doco. Look at how people yo-yo so easily when they use poor dietary advice and excercise regimes…. cheers. IP

  • Diety
    August 26, 2010
    Reply #18
    GD Star Rating
    loading...

    i like my boody ,.

  • Eric
    August 26, 2010
    Reply #19
    GD Star Rating
    loading...

    well, if it\’s true, it sucks and I blame you for my woes. I can probably get down to 150 and be a lean mofo but I don\’t want to be 150 I want to be 160 and be a lean mofo but my body does not want to coperate. Thank you for giving me something to blame FJ, woot excuses.

    J/K,…kinda.

    hmm is this kind of like bodyfat setpoint theory? I have a horrible memory for most things so I\’ll have to go back and read.

    SOFTCORE

    • - Fit Jerk -
      August 27, 2010
      Reply #20
      GD Star Rating
      loading...

      Hey! do I see excuse making? Don’t make me kick your ass Eric. I’ve been practicing my flying armbars… and oh boy, have they gotten potent.

      And I see you suffer from abysmal short term memory like me. Sucks when you get into an argument and you need to reference something you read and its like… “shitfuck god damn it!… can’t remember!”

      It’s why I love OneNote. That program… was “my” idea.

      • Eric
        August 27, 2010
        Reply #21
        GD Star Rating
        loading...

        Wait….what were we talking about?

        I use Evernote, I’ll hace to check onenote

  • Capt_Healthy
    August 27, 2010
    Reply #22
    GD Star Rating
    loading...

    @FitJerk, awesome article! I believe you’re onto something huge. FitJerk, if you need help or volunteer for this study I’m willing to contribute my bodyweight/training stats.
    Growing up I played football & wrestled in high-school. My natural body weight was around 185-190. I never cut weight for wrestling until I got to college. I wrestled @ 174 and would walk-around 10 pounds over and cut down in about 3-5 days to make weight. It was hard @ the beginning of the season; then It became easier each “cut”. It’s been about 4 years since that time. I’ve maintained my natural weight of 185-190. However, I recently competes in a Natural BB competition. I chose middle weight (165-176) b/c it wuz in my range from wrestling & I new I could get “ripped”. Nevertheless it was very challenging getting back down to that weight. I finally squeaked in @ 175 on the day of weigh-in. After the BB show; I was mentally exhausted & tired of dieting. I ballooned all the way up to 210 in about 2 weeks & felt horrible. I decided to get back on my “regular” routine & have returned to my natural bodyweight of 185-190 in about 5/6 week time frame from the BB show. Credits to FitJerk for helping me get ready, I applied his philosophy on “reverse-rep count” really helped to push through those tough sets. I also had to lay-off the Peanut Butter, LOL even though it has great nutrients, I was abusing it & taking in too many calories.

  • Zack NUtter
    August 29, 2010
    Reply #23
    GD Star Rating
    loading...

    Did you come up with this theory on your own if so it is pretty inlighting I have experianced the same thing in my weight managment but never thought about it like this.

  • Dave - Not Your Average Fitness Tips
    August 30, 2010
    Reply #24
    GD Star Rating
    loading...

    Great theory…I’ve thought the same thing over the years. When I’m cutting fat, my body gets to a point where it doesn’t really want to go any further (around 135lbs). When I try to add muscle, after 145lbs, my body seems like it would rather add fat. Certainly a challenge to break this cycle.

  • FLo_
    September 3, 2010
    Reply #25
    GD Star Rating
    loading...

    yeah i’m another victim here…can’t get past 180 -.-” and I eat shitloads of food ( let’s think at the period when we are dieting…I mean damn I ate 2k cals for alot of time when I was 190 to get to 170 + 6 meals a day ( past bs…) I was hungry all the time -.-” and I couldn’t wait for the next day to eat again something…
    Now I am full all the time ( we..who are bulking )..and It’s becoming progresively harder to eat something

    Also your security system is beying rude again…( SPANKME? <–surprize but sex xD ) , your system is like bulking..it's progresiely harder to write the words :) )lmao

  • david
    October 17, 2010
    Reply #26
    GD Star Rating
    loading...

    im a personal trainer and i notice this as well. i think once you are weighing a good weight, it becomes harder to gain or lose weight for people because muscle tone takes a long time to build. fat on the other hand is much easier to ad…

  • Athletic tape
    November 2, 2010
    Reply #27
    GD Star Rating
    loading...

    You should be proud of your blog
    I really enjoy reading your blog.

  • Anoop
    December 2, 2010
    Reply #28
    GD Star Rating
    loading...

    It’s called set point theory. Some say it is settling point. It’s been known a while back. This one reason why 90% of the people put all the weight back.

    Just search st point theory in google

    • Dell
      November 16, 2011
      Reply #29
      GD Star Rating
      loading...

      I literally jupmed out of my chair and danced after reading this!

Leave a Reply:



*
To prove you're a person (not a spam script), type the security word shown in the picture.
Anti-spam image


Pin It Resources For The Ultimate Body

rapid abs

FJ's Latest Reviews FJ’s Archive Of Brilliance
Login

Read Another:
Supplement Review: ZizZazz Explosive Energy Mix

. Product Name:ZizZazz Explosive Energy Mix Company: ZizZazz MSRP: $31.84 per box Click For Lowest Price On ZizZazz Energy! Availability: Medium-Low (Mainly Online) Instant gratification. A concept that is an innovative driver and simultaneously the downfall of humanity. Our obsession for instant gratification has led us to some kick ass...

Close