So, you’ve heard me (along with many other experts) preach and say that you need to eat at least 6 meals a day. Then we have a few panzies who disagree for the sake of starting an argument and say “its all BS… You don’t need to eat that many meals a day… Just eat 4000 calories in one meal and then coast”. See the comments in my 10 tips to lose 10lbs article for some foolish hilarity.
Anyways back to my point, you DO need to eat frequently because it works – and it doesn’t matter if you’re trying to gain weight or lose weight. What you eat in each of those meals along with the type of training that you do is what will have a direct impact on your success. But since we’re all busy as HELL these days, we barely have enough time to cook & prepare our 5-6 daily meals (I should know, I’m constantly over worked… I’m always telling this person to do that, that person to do this and pointing fingers and shit – gets exhausting). So what to do? Enter super-convenient protein and energy bars.
They’re jam packed with nutrients, minerals and vitamins and come in a million different flavors and in a million different types. Some are meant for recovery and are full of protein, some are meant for pre-workout and are carb heavy, some are meant to help you lose weight, and on and on. I think today, “bars” can adhere to almost ANY need that you may have when it comes to nutrition… BUT, are they really as “healthy” and “nutritious” as they claim to be?
Well let’s find out. Before deciding on what brand to buy or what ingredient content to look for, you need to pick your GOAL because we have so many freakin’ choices, there is no ONE energy or protein bar that will do everything for you. It’s all been specialized… Gone are the days when you could use the same ol’ PowerBar® for pre and post workout. As far as I’m concerned, here are the categories that you need to consider:
- Pre workout (Bars that have just enough carbs to fuel your workouts)
- Pre workout energy (I’ve seen bars that now contain ingredients similar to those found in energy drinks… So maybe you need a pick-me-up?)
- Post workout (No time to mix up a protein shake? Running late? A high-protein post-workout bar may be for you)
- Meal Replacement (Working long hours and need to replace a meal with a nice light snack? You might want to look into these)
Now, don’t go all hay-wire and be like: “I need to fulfill ALL those categories”. That’s bullshit – you’re telling me that every meal in your day is going to be a convenience food packed inside a wrapper? Something’s wrong with you. If 3 jobs are getting in the way of you bettering your health… Then quit one of your fucking jobs! You’ll survive, I promise. So my suggestion is to pick ONE of those categories and set out on a quest to find your perfect bar.
What makes a good bar? Well here are a few of FJ’s rules of thumb to follow when picking out a protein or energy bar:
- Watch the saturated fat content. I saw an Atkin’s Advantage Chocolate bar which had 8g of saturated fat. That’s the same amount you get in a McDonald’s Quarter Pounder Cheeseburger. Haha… So much for the “advantage”.
- SUGAR! Some protein bars have so much sugar to mask their disgusting taste that you might as well eat an OhHenry (I’m dead serious). Find ones that have around 4-5g or less per bar. If you come across ones that are sweetened with Splenda… It’s not a bad choice. Even though I’m not a huge fan of sugar substitutes (except Stevia), Splenda (sucralose) has shown to be quite safe. I’m still keeping my eyes open on that stuff though.
- Carbs. Ok so you want a bar to fuel your workout, that doesn’t mean you need to do a carb-overload! A bar that as a moderate amount of carbs (20-25g) will be MUCH better for you than ones that have very HIGH amount of carbs. Only serious athletes such as bodybuilders or long distance runners need the high-carb bars as far as I’m concerned.
- Fiber – Something you should look for if you’re into meal replacement. A bar with 5-7g of fiber will ensure that you’ve had your 1/3 of the recommended fiber serving for that day. Not too shabby. Also remember that fiber helps keep you feeling “fuller” for longer AND a high fiber diet has shown to help your body absorb FEWER calories at the end of the day.
- Overall calories. With the exception of post-workout bars you should look for ones that have no more than 350 calories per bar. 200 if you’re looking for a nice mid-day snack.
- It doesn’t matter what bar you eat… Remember to drink at least a FULL GLASS of water along with them. 99% of the bars are extremely nutrient dense and you need to make it easier for your body to digest and absorb everything. Otherwise… You’ll shit it out and you’ve just wasted your money.
So what about taste? Well I won’t lie… finding one that taste’s good while meeting all the “healthy” criteria is a bitch, so you’re just going to have to take a few chances. A lot of the times high fibre bars have boat loads of sugar to mask their taste. Or sometimes low sugar bars will end up having artery-clogging levels of saturated fat. I doubt you’ll ever find a perfect bar, but there are ones out there that are GOOD ENOUGH.
These will get you by… But remember that NOTHING replaces whole foods. These are for convenience purposes only, so don’t become some energy bar addict. In the end, an energy or protein bar is USUALLY better for you than junk food, and because you have so many options I’d say it can be a healthy choice as long as you know what to look for. Eat up!
To Being Fit & Sexy 4 Life!
- Fit Jerk
P.S – Oh and a side note – to lessen your chances of wasting tonnes of cash going through every bar possible, check back here often as I will be putting quite a few protein bars to the test in the near future. This will be a Bronze/Gold member exclusive so make sure you’re a member! It’s FREE; just sign up by pressing the “register” button in the login box to your left.
QQ (Quick Question) – Do you eat protein/energy bars? If so what brand and what kind… post below!
loading...










June 13, 2009
#1
loading...
yes I eat an energy bar called Mt-n-Man Chia Bar. I like the Chocolate P-nut Butter the best but their are three other flavors
June 15, 2009
#2
loading...
I’ve always had to look at the carb and sugar content of all these bars due to being a type ii diabetic, and a LOT are packed with so much that for me, it totally cancels out any “nuttitional value” it has. I think if someone took one of those bars and held it next to a Snickers bar and compared, they would be pretty shocked at the similarities.
June 15, 2009
#3
loading...
I agree with Cher about the similarities between candy bars and so called nutrition bars, lol By the way, if you look up how to make your own energy bars on google, you will find plenty of recipes. Some sites even have tables that compare various brands and or types of energy bars for their fat, protein, and calorie contents. My brother is a borderline hypoglycemic, if he eats a regular diet, his sugar is stable. If my brother eats sweets, his blood sugar can shoot up. I realize that, if he lets his sugar level go up and down by eating sweets, he could eventually have trouble with his insulin levels. I think many folks become type 2 diabetics via drinking and eating a lot of high sugar foods.
Most people know about candy needing to be eaten in moderation, but they don’t think twice about eating processed foods high in sugar like cereals, cookies, ice cream and even empty calorie foods like chips and crackers, etc raise blood sugar. People also don’t check the serving sizes, one vitamin water can have 2.5 servings per bottle or more at 50 calories per serving, and other energy drinks are the same if not worse.
Have a great week
June 15, 2009
#4
loading...
Hmm, your brother needs to concentrate on eating Low Glycemic foods so the sugar is constantly but evenly released into his blood stream. (I’m sure he does)
If you don’t use too much sugar, Whey Crisps can make kick ass protein bars.
And vitamin water? HA… yeah that bottle of crap is a JOKE. At an average of 25g sugar per bottle, it’s a moronic way of getting your daily vitamins. Better off with multi-vitamins.
June 16, 2009
#5
loading...
I have always kept way from bars like this. I thought they were candy bars wrapped to look healthy.
I also avoid artificial colours, flavours, preservatives, and sweetners. Most I’ve seen have these in them and the body can do without them.
I would be interested in reviews you do on genuinely healthy meal replacment bars. A couple of days a week I find myself squeezing in a full days work before getting the kids from school at 3pm. Then, Oops I remember I forgot to eat lunch and need a meal on the go.
This is a great topic to explore. Thanks, FJ.
June 16, 2009
#6
loading...
Looking forward to your review of bars. I do read the labels & look for a decent amount of protein & carbs in the range but not more per your article if it is just a mini meal thing. I definitely look at the saturated fats. Crazy how many bars have that high saturated fat.
I do my best but can’t always fine what I want. I have a few I can live with. I am not one to have to have everything perfect. I do make my own as well so I keep them along with a couple others on hand & constantly looking for anything better.
June 16, 2009
#7
loading...
Yep, it’s a hard find. Needle in a haystack kind of hard…
Jody, which are these bars that you say you can “live with”. Any names? I need names woman! ..
I’ll be reviewing a few from a company called Kashi. I’ve heard some positive things about them so let’s see what they’ve come up with.
June 17, 2009
#8
loading...
Well, I don’t want to be reprimanded by you!!! Like I said, I am not a perfect eater & just look for things that I can live with taste & ingredient wise. I mostly need ones with protein because I always want protein with my bars. Kashi tend to be higher carb bars so I don’t eat those.
I also look for bars that meet my needs at different times of day.. like breakfast, I don’t want chocolate flavor.. if I need a lunch time one & god forbid, I miss dinner, I look for something a bit more substantial.
I am gonna double check my bars before I tell you!!! I know the sugar grams on a couple may not make you happy!
June 17, 2009
#9
loading...
Whaa..? you DONT want chocolate for breakfast? Comon now… we all know that chocolate and candy make the best breakfast *cough* Lamar Odom *cough*.
But don’t worry, I won’t poke too much fun at your sugary content bars. Hah.
June 22, 2009
#10
loading...
Hi FJ. Things have been a bit crazy & just have not had time to do a lot extra lately & now 4 grandkids in town!
As for bars & I love to check them out, there are a lot of better natural & organic bars out there that I don’t eat just because of either taste OR too much fat, even if it is good fat. I don’t want to eat a bar with 15-20 grams of fat even if only 2 grams are saturated. I want food for that many fat grams. Also, I always am looking for at least 14 to 20+ grams of protein & no more than 30 grams of carbs based on what I eat the bars for.. I don’t eat any higher carb/lower protein bars.
As for sugar gram, saturated fat & such, I tend to look at my “diet” over the course of a day or many days.. so as long at that all works out over a period of a few days, I don’t get too caught up in having to have every meal fit the sugar gram or minimal saturated fat rule. It is what your total days or weeks make up looks like for me.
So saying that, some bars I eat:
Fruitified Zone Perfect – Blueberry; Doctor’s CarbRite Diet; ThinkThin High Protein bar; Zero Impact High Protein Meal bar; 2:1 oatmeal bar by Anti-Aging Essentials: PureFit (like this one cause no coating so it will last if you need to take out in the heat!)
There you have it but I am always looking!
PS: I am sure I saw some video of a someone walking a cat on a leash!
June 26, 2009
#11
loading...
These protein bars are formulated by knowledgeable fitness professionals and are part of a site that gives you leading edge information and resources in the fitness field. Make sure the products you choose are FDA approved so that the ingredients listed are what you are actually getting. These handy bars are designed to be nutritious meals on the run and are a great concept in forwarding fitness.
July 8, 2009
#12
loading...
i like the snickers marathon bars. i prefer the chocolate nut burst ones cause they’re Not covered in chocolate which easily melts and becomes a big mess. they make a good meal replacement. not bad before the gym cause the carbs and potassium, but with 11 grams of fiber, you stomach won’t feel too peachy.
i appreciate the honest and direct reviews there FJ ~_*
July 20, 2009
#13
loading...
The chocolate nut burst has 9g of fat… not quite the ideal choice. If you ARE going to try the Snickers Marathon’s, go for the Honey & Toasted Almonds. At 4.5g of fat, they are reasonable… specially coming from Snickers.
Oh and here’s a SHOCKER: They don’t tell you the sugar content of these bars on their site. HA!
(And the reviews will stay honest, I promise you that)
July 20, 2009
#14
loading...
Awesome post! I love your writing style. I found this article while browsing through this week’s Total Mind and Body Fitness Carnival. I’m definitely going to browse this site a bit more.
I recently created a post on my own blog, Salad Sticks, about interesting articles found in the carnival and included your blog entry.
http://www.saladsticks.com/2009/07/total-mind-and-body-fitness-carnival.html
Thanks for the good read!
July 20, 2009
#15
loading...
Glad you liked it, comments like these make me wanan do pushups. Keep em comin’
And big ups for the mention on your blog… that’s truly awesome sauce.
July 22, 2009
#16
loading...
I agree; this post was a standout from the carnival. I’ve actually started working out only just recently (within the month) and I have been giving slight thought to a protein bar but I have not taken the time to learn anything about which one’s are worth my money. This article will be a nice starting point for me; I’m thinking something that doesn’t taste great is probably the way to go but you never know what these food engineers can come up with until you try them.
July 22, 2009
#17
loading...
Thanks for submitting to my blog carnival. This was the best article by far! I love your non-bs approach on the site too. Keep up the great work and feel free to add another post for next weeks carnival!
~Ryan
July 29, 2009
#18
loading...
Thanks for your contribution to Take Charge of Your Health Care Carnival. My readers will appreciate this excellent information on protein and energy bars.
October 5, 2009
#19
loading...
what did peeps do before these bars came out? isn’t clean the best?
October 5, 2009
#20
loading...
Not sure, but I’m pretty sure they were forced to eat GOOD food… how unfortunate for them eh? No sugary bars with an overdose in sodium, coupled with sneaky “natural” marketing. They sure missed out!
November 14, 2009
#21
loading...
I’ am a big fan of the Pure Protein brand protein bars. 180 calories for 20 grams of protein, less than 100mg of sodium, VERY low cholesterol, and they don’t taste too bad.
I’ve seen some protein bars (and powders for that matter) that have a disgustingly high amount of cholesterol… how do people eat that shit?
January 16, 2010
#22
loading...
I’m almost 80, so not too interested in fitness. Just good health. We don’t eat much beef, so I will be watching for your reviews. That chocolate beef drink sounds yummy. Thanks for your site.
February 1, 2010
#23
loading...
Hi, i read your post and i like it. I think that there is good information about the protein powder.
February 2, 2010
#24
loading...
Hi, your post is good and i think protein is a very important nutrient for our body that cannot be produced naturally. Almost all of us are aware of the importance of protein. You will have to make sure that you add protein in your diet either way.
April 5, 2010
#25
loading...
all the protein bars I’ve tried have tasted like crap and some of them retail as high as $5, a traditional mrp shake is far better value and tastes far nicer.